Have you ever spotted a charge on your credit card statement that you didn't recognize or authorize? Or been dissatisfied with a purchase, but the merchant refused to refund your money? You're not alone. Lending Tree finds that 50% of consumers have disputed a charge on their credit card at some point.

While dealing with payment disputes can be stressful and time-consuming, consumers have a powerful tool at their disposal: the chargeback. A chargeback is a formal dispute process where your bank forcibly reverses a charge from a merchant and returns the funds to your account. When used correctly for valid claims, chargebacks protect against fraud, errors, and subpar goods and services.

However, many consumers don't fully understand their chargeback rights or how to navigate the dispute process effectively. As a result, merchants generally have a chargeback win rate of 20-30%, often due to insufficient evidence or avoidable consumer mistakes.

Don't let unfamiliar processes or lack of knowledge stop you from fighting back against incorrect charges. This comprehensive guide breaks down everything you need to know to file a chargeback and win.

• The difference between chargebacks and refunds
• Common scenarios that qualify for a legitimate chargeback
• How to gather compelling evidence to support your claim
• Step-by-step instructions for filing a dispute with your card issuer
• Tips for communicating with merchants and banks during the process
• Mistakes to avoid that will get your case denied

We'll arm you with the tools and confidence to dispute any invalid charge and protect your hard-earned money. Let's get started!

What Is a Chargeback?

A chargeback is a formal dispute process initiated by a consumer to reverse a credit or debit card transaction and recoup their money. When a consumer files a chargeback with their card issuer, the bank forcibly takes the funds from the merchant's account and returns them to the consumer.

This is different from a regular refund, which is handled internally by the merchant. With a refund, the merchant voluntarily agrees to return the consumer's money, usually due to issues like item returns, order cancellations, or customer satisfaction issues.

Some key differences between chargebacks and refunds:

• Chargebacks are initiated through the consumer's bank, while refunds are initiated through the merchant and processed through a payment processor
• Chargebacks can be filed for fraudulent charges, errors, or quality disputes, while refunds are generally for returns or customer service issues
• Chargebacks forcibly reverse funds from the merchant's account, while refunds are issued voluntarily by the merchant
• Chargebacks have formal filing deadlines and documentation requirements, while merchant refund policies vary

Chargebacks provide consumers an important layer of protection against unauthorized charges, billing errors, or unresolved disputes with a merchant. However, they are generally meant to be used as a last resort after the consumer has attempted to resolve the issue with the merchant directly.

When to File a Chargeback

Not all transaction disputes are eligible for chargebacks. Filing frivolous claims can lead to your case being denied and even get you flagged as an abusive filer. Here are the main situations when a chargeback is legitimate:

Fraudulent or Unauthorized Charges

Credit card chargebacks were originally designed to protect consumers against credit card fraud. If you see a charge you don't recognize and didn't authorize, you can dispute it as fraudulent. Common examples include:

• Purchases made with a lost or stolen card
• Charges that appear after your card information was compromised in a data breach
• Unauthorized transactions made by a family member, friend, or colleague

If you suspect fraud, contact your bank immediately to report the charge and have your card frozen or reissued. Most card issuers offer zero liability protection if you promptly report fraudulent activity.

Merchant Error

Sometimes a merchant makes a legitimate mistake when processing your transaction. These errors are usually clear-cut and easy to identify on your statement. Chargeback-worthy merchant errors include:

• Incorrect charge amount (e.g. you were charged $250 instead of $25)
• Duplicate charges for a single transaction
• Recurring subscription charged after cancellation

If you notice an obvious error, first contact the merchant to see if they can fix it. If the merchant is uncooperative or unresponsive, proceed with a chargeback.

Quality or Service Disputes

Chargebacks can also provide recourse when you're dissatisfied with the quality of a product or service. Quality disputes are more subjective than fraud or errors, making them harder to win. A quality dispute may be eligible for a chargeback if:

• Item is defective, damaged, or significantly not as described
• Merchant sends a counterfeit version of the item ordered
• Service is not performed as agreed upon or to a reasonable standard

To have a strong case, you'll need evidence that the merchant failed to deliver on what was promised. If an item arrives damaged, take photos before sending it back. Save emails or screenshots of service agreements that weren't honored.

These disputes often hinge on whether you've made a good-faith attempt to resolve the issue directly with the merchant first. Your chargeback may be denied if you don't allow the merchant to correct the problem or process a refund.

Non-Delivery

You may have grounds for a chargeback if you pay for an item or service but never receive it. However, non-delivery can be tricky to prove, especially for online purchases. Before filing a chargeback for non-delivery:

• Check the merchant's shipping timeframe and allow reasonable time for delivery
• Contact the merchant to see if they have tracking information or can reship the item
• See if the merchant requires you to file a claim with the shipping carrier first

If the merchant isn't responsive or can't provide proof the item was delivered, then a chargeback may be your best recourse.

Ineligible Chargeback Reasons

Not all reasons for dissatisfaction with a purchase are grounds for a chargeback. Invalid chargeback situations include:

• Buyer's remorse or regretting the purchase
• Misunderstanding the merchant's return policy
• A family member or friend made the purchase without your knowledge
• Forgetting about or not recognizing a recurring subscription charge

Chargebacks aren't meant to be an alternative to a merchant's return process or a way to avoid paying for buyer's remorse. Only file a chargeback if you have a legitimate dispute and have exhausted options for resolving it directly with the merchant.

Gathering Evidence to Support Your Claim

Chargeback disputes often involve a "he said, she said" situation between the merchant and consumer. The more compelling evidence you have to support your claim, the better your chances of winning. Start gathering documentation the instant you suspect an issue with a transaction—don't wait until you're ready to file the dispute.

Keep Good Records

The first step in the evidence-gathering process is to maintain detailed records of your purchases. For online transactions, this includes:

• Saving order confirmation emails
• Printing or screenshotting purchase receipts
• Noting down dates of phone or in-person interactions with the merchant

For in-store purchases, always ask for a printed receipt. If the merchant offers digital receipts via email or app, opt-in to those also.

Correspondence With the Merchant

If you've attempted to resolve a dispute directly with the merchant, document all those interactions. This includes:

• Saving emails back and forth with customer service representatives
• Screenshotting chat logs from online support portals
• Taking notes during phone calls, including date, time, and name of representative
• Printing any letters or forms you submitted as part of the merchant's dispute process

If the merchant makes any offers or promises to resolve the issue, make sure to capture those in writing.

Tracking and Delivery Information

For disputes involving non-receipt of goods, you'll need evidence to show the item wasn't delivered as promised. Collect documentation such as:

• Shipping confirmation emails from the merchant
• Tracking numbers and delivery status from the carrier (UPS, FedEx, USPS, etc.)
• Screenshots of "out for delivery" or "delivered" notifications
• Photos of damaged packages or items upon arrival

Print copies of the merchant's stated shipping timeframe or estimated release dates if you're dealing with a pre-ordered or back-ordered item.

Condition of Products/Services

Quality disputes require compelling evidence demonstrating that the product or service didn't meet expectations. Types of documentation may include:

• Photos or videos of damaged, defective, or not-as-described items
• Copies of contracts, agreements, or invoices outlining service deliverables
• Screenshots or recordings of sub-par digital goods like ebooks, courses, or subscription content

The more specific you can get, the better. Capture serial numbers, model names, course titles, and other identifying details.

Bank Statements and Card Issuer Policies

Scan your bank statements to identify the specific charge(s) you're disputing. Highlight or circle the line item(s) and be prepared to provide the statement as supporting documentation.

Reviewing your card issuer's chargeback policies and procedures is also a good idea. Print or save copies of:

• Timeline and deadlines for filing disputes
• Required forms or affidavits
• Lists of acceptable supporting evidence
• Conditions for eligibility

This information will make it easier to ensure you're following the proper procedures and not missing any steps when it comes time to file.

Organize and Prepare Your Evidence

Once you've gathered all relevant documentation, take some time to organize it chronologically. Create a folder or binder with everything pertaining to the transaction in question, from oldest to most recent.

As you're organizing, make note of any missing pieces. If you lack a critical form of evidence, like proof of delivery or photos of damage, see if you can fill in the gaps before filing your dispute. The more complete and well-organized your evidence is, the stronger your case will be in the eyes of your bank or card issuer.

Filing the Chargeback Claim

Once you've gathered strong evidence, you can initiate the formal chargeback process with your bank or card issuer. While exact procedures vary by financial institution, the general steps are as follows:

Contact Your Bank or Card Issuer

Call the customer service number on the back of your credit or debit card. Some issuers also allow you to dispute a charge through your online banking portal or mobile app.

Provide Transaction Details

The representative will ask for details about the transaction you're disputing, including:

• Merchant name
• Transaction date
• Dollar amount
• Reason for the chargeback

Refer to your card statement to provide accurate information. The representative will likely give you a reference number for your claim - write this down for future follow-up.

Submit Your Evidence

The representative will instruct you on how to submit the evidence you've gathered. You may be asked to:

• Mail or fax copies of documentation
• Upload files through an online portal
• Fill out and sign an affidavit affirming your claim

Follow the submission instructions carefully and make copies of everything you send in. If you're mailing physical documents, consider using certified mail for tracking purposes.

Participate in the Investigation

After you've filed your initial claim, the card issuer will begin investigating the customer dispute. They may contact you for additional information or clarification. Respond promptly to any requests to avoid delays or denials.

In some cases, the card issuer may ask you to make a good-faith attempt to resolve the issue with the merchant before proceeding with the chargeback. If you haven't already done so, contact the merchant and document your attempts to reach a resolution.

Communicating with Merchants and Banks

Effective communication with all parties involved in the dispute (your bank, the card network, and the merchant) improves your chances of a successful chargeback. Here are some tips:

Be Professional and Factual

When corresponding with merchants or bank representatives, keep your communications concise and stick to the transaction's facts. Avoid making emotional appeals or angry accusations, as this can undermine credibility.

Provide Relevant Details

Include details like dates, dollar amounts, and transaction/confirmation numbers in your communications. This helps all parties quickly locate the transaction and move the case forward.

Set Clear Expectations

If you're communicating with a merchant about a refund or return, be clear about what resolution you're seeking and your expected timeline. Consider phrases like "I am requesting a full refund to my original form of payment within the next five business days."

Keep Accurate Records

As with gathering initial evidence, document all communications throughout the dispute process. Save emails, take screenshots of chat sessions, and note down dates and times of phone calls. You may need to provide these records to your bank or card issuer as the investigation unfolds.

Avoiding Common Mistakes

Certain missteps can derail your chargeback dispute even with a legitimate claim and compelling evidence. Watch out for these common pitfalls:

Missing Deadlines

Credit card issuers have strict timelines for filing chargeback claims, usually within 60-120 days of the transaction date. Once you've initiated a claim, you may have additional deadlines for submitting evidence or responding to requests for information. Set reminders and submit everything on time.

Failing to Attempt Merchant Resolution

While not always required, attempting to resolve an issue directly with the merchant before resorting to a chargeback strengthens your case. Card issuers want to see that you made a good-faith effort to settle the dispute through other channels first.

Submitting Insufficient Evidence

Failing to provide convincing evidence is one of the most common reasons banks deny chargeback claims. Before submitting your rebuttal letter and documentation, ask yourself:

• Does this clearly demonstrate the error or issue with the transaction?
• Is the key information like dates and dollar amounts visible/legible?
• Would a neutral third party be convinced by this evidence?

If you're unsure, err on the side of over-documenting rather than providing too little support for your claim.

Giving Up After Initial Denial

In some cases, card issuers may initially deny a chargeback claim due to insufficient evidence or a merchant rebuttal letter. Don't be discouraged—you have the right to appeal the decision or file additional evidence for reconsideration. Persistence pays off, especially if you have a strong case.

Abusing Chargeback Rights

Chargeback abuse, or friendly fraud, occurs when consumers file illegitimate chargebacks for valid transactions. Some examples include:

• Claiming non-delivery for an item that arrived on time
• Disputing a charge for buyer's remorse
• Filing a chargeback without contacting the merchant first

A high chargeback ratio hurts merchants and can get you flagged as a high-risk customer with your bank. Only file chargebacks for legitimate credit card disputes to avoid consequences like account closure or legal action.

What to Expect After Filing

The chargeback dispute process can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months, depending on the complexity of the case and the financial institutions involved. Here's a general timeline of what happens after you file:

1. Initial Review: The card issuer reviews your claim and evidence to determine if it meets the criteria for a chargeback. This can take 1-2 billing cycles.
2. Provisional Credit: If your claim is accepted for investigation, the card issuer may issue a provisional credit to your account while the case is pending. This is usually equal to the disputed amount.
3. Merchant Response: The card issuer notifies the merchant's bank of the chargeback. The merchant has a set timeframe (usually 30-45 days) to respond with their own evidence to dispute the claim.
4. Final Decision: The card issuer reviews the evidence from both sides and makes a final decision to resolve the chargeback in favor of either the cardholder or the merchant. If you lose the case, the provisional credit will be reversed.
5. Customer Notification: The card issuer notifies you of the outcome and any further actions needed, like returning products or submitting additional appeals. If you disagree with the decision, you typically have 10-14 days to file an appeal with the card network for arbitration.

Throughout the process, stay in contact with your credit card issuer and respond promptly to any requests for additional information. Check your account regularly to monitor the status of any provisional credits.

Tips for Specific Dispute Situations

While the general chargeback process is similar across dispute types, certain situations may require additional actions or evidence.

Unauthorized Transactions

If you suspect your card was used without your permission, take these steps immediately:

• Contact your bank to report the fraudulent activity and request a new card
• File a police report, especially for large dollar amounts
• Provide bank statements highlighting the unauthorized charges
• Sign an affidavit affirming you didn't make or authorize the purchases

Swift action is key - the Fair Credit Billing Act limits your liability for unauthorized charges to $50 if you report them within 2 business days.

Quality or Service Issues

Chargebacks for defective products or unsatisfactory services can be tricky to prove. Your evidence should demonstrate a clear discrepancy between what was promised and what was delivered.

• Provide photos or videos documenting the issue, like a stained garment or shoddy workmanship
• Include copies of written contracts, warranty agreements, or service terms not met by the merchant
• Obtain expert testimony or repair estimates to bolster your case

If you've already returned the item, include tracking information and proof of receipt by the merchant.

Subscription or Recurring Charges

If you've been charged for a subscription you canceled or a service you didn't agree to, you'll need to prove you took proper steps to stop the charges.

• Provide copies of your cancellation confirmation, like an email or screenshot

Handle Chargebacks with Zen Payments

At Zen Payments, we help merchants handle all their payment processing needs, from online e-commerce to retail, including managing chargeback disputes. Contact us today to get started.